When Should I Offer Free Shipping (and When Not To)?
Free shipping boosts sales but kills margins if done wrong. Learn when to offer free shipping and when to hold back for e-commerce success.
Free shipping has become one of the most powerful conversion boosters in e-commerce. In fact, research shows that 79% of customers are more likely to shop online if free shipping is offered.
But here's the catch: free shipping isn't free for the store. SMBs and dropshippers often lose margins by giving away shipping too easily—or lose sales by not offering it at all.
So how do you decide when to offer free shipping and when to hold back? That's what this guide is all about.
Why Free Shipping Works
Free shipping influences both perception and behavior:
- Eliminates surprises → Hidden costs at checkout are the #1 cause of cart abandonment.
- Builds trust → Transparent pricing makes customers feel treated fairly.
- Encourages larger orders → Free shipping thresholds motivate customers to add more to their cart.
- Levels the playing field → Competing with Amazon? You can't ignore shipping expectations.
When You Should Offer Free Shipping
1. On High-Margin Products
If your margins are strong, you can absorb shipping costs without hurting profitability.
👉 Example: Selling electronics accessories with 60% margin? Free shipping can pay for itself through higher conversion.
2. With Order Thresholds
Set a minimum order value for free shipping (e.g., "Free shipping on orders over $50").
- Increases average order value (AOV).
- Protects margins on small-ticket items.
- Feels like a win-win for the shopper.
3. During Promotions or Seasonal Sales
Use free shipping as a limited-time incentive:
- "Black Friday: Free Shipping on All Orders!"
- "Back-to-School Deals + Free Shipping Today Only."
This adds urgency without committing to permanent free shipping.
4. For Loyal Customers
Reward loyalty by making free shipping part of a membership or subscription.
- Examples: Amazon Prime, Walmart+
- For SMBs: offer free shipping after 5 orders or as part of a VIP program.
5. When Competitors Do It
If your competitors are offering free shipping on similar products, you can't afford not to.
📊 Tools like PriceSense help you track not only prices but promotions, letting you match shipping offers strategically.
When You Should Not Offer Free Shipping
1. On Low-Margin Products
If shipping eats 30–40% of your profit, free shipping will kill your margins. In this case, use thresholds or bundle shipping into the product price.
2. For International Orders
International shipping costs vary wildly. Offering free shipping globally can bankrupt SMBs. Instead:
- Offer free domestic shipping only.
- Charge fair, transparent international rates.
3. On Oversized or Heavy Items
Furniture, gym equipment, or appliances have high freight costs. In these cases:
- Be upfront about shipping.
- Offer "discounted shipping" instead of "free shipping."
4. When It's Not Industry Standard
In some niches (like luxury goods), customers care more about exclusivity and quality than free shipping. Here, it's better to position premium service over price savings.
How to Make Free Shipping Work Without Losing Money
- Bake It Into Prices
Increase product price slightly to cover shipping. Customers focus on "free shipping," not small product price differences. - Negotiate With Carriers
UPS, FedEx, and DHL often give SMBs discounted rates if volume grows. - Use Flat-Rate Shipping
Offer a simple flat rate across most orders to reduce complexity. - Track Competitor Promotions
If your competitors start offering free shipping, consider following suit—PriceSense alerts help you stay on top of these shifts.
Case Study: Dropshipper Balances Free Shipping With Margins
A dropshipper selling phone accessories saw high cart abandonment at checkout due to $7.99 shipping fees.
Solution:
- Introduced free shipping for orders over $40.
- Increased product prices by $1–$2 across the store.
- Promoted "Free Shipping Weekends" during slow periods.
Result:
- Cart abandonment dropped by 18%.
- Average order value rose by 22%.
- Profitability stayed intact.
Common Mistakes With Free Shipping
- ❌ Offering free shipping on everything, regardless of margins.
- ❌ Ignoring international and oversized product costs.
- ❌ Failing to highlight free shipping clearly in ads and product pages.
- ❌ Copying competitors blindly without tracking profitability.
FAQ: Free Shipping in E-Commerce
Q: Should I always offer free shipping?
No. It works best with high-margin items, thresholds, or promotions—not on every product.
Q: Is free shipping better than discounts?
Often yes—customers perceive "free shipping" as more valuable than a 10% discount.
Q: How do I cover free shipping costs?
Bake costs into product prices, set thresholds, or negotiate better shipping rates.
Q: Can free shipping reduce cart abandonment?
Yes—unexpected shipping costs are the #1 reason shoppers abandon carts.
Conclusion
Free shipping can be a powerful weapon for reducing cart abandonment, increasing order value, and staying competitive. But it's not a one-size-fits-all strategy.
Use it when:
- Margins are strong.
- You can set order thresholds.
- You want to boost loyalty or promotions.
Avoid it when margins are too thin, shipping costs are unpredictable, or your industry doesn't expect it.
👉 The key is balance—and tools like PriceSense help you monitor competitors so you know exactly when free shipping gives you the edge.
🚀 Try PriceSense Free and start aligning your shipping strategy with competitive pricing today.
Start tracking competitor prices today
Join thousands of users optimizing their pricing strategy
