How to Set the Right Price for a New Product in Your Online Store
Learn how to set the right price for new products in your online store. Balance costs, competition & psychology to maximize conversions in 2025.
How to Set the Right Price for a New Product in Your Online Store
You've found a great product, sourced it, built a page on Shopify or WooCommerce, and now comes the hardest part: what price should you set?
For e-commerce owners in 2025, pricing is one of the most important decisions. Set it too high, and customers abandon your site. Too low, and you eat into profits. The right price maximizes conversions and margins—but getting there requires strategy, not guesswork.
This guide walks you through a step-by-step framework for pricing new products in your online store, with actionable tips SMBs and dropshippers can use today.
Why Pricing Matters More Than Ever in 2025
- Shoppers compare instantly: A customer can check Amazon, Walmart, and your store in seconds.
- Ads are more expensive: You can't afford to waste PPC spend promoting uncompetitive prices.
- Margins are tighter: Supplier costs and shipping fees are rising, leaving less room for error.
- Trust is fragile: Fake discounts or arbitrary prices push customers away for good.
Pricing isn't just math—it's psychology, competition, and strategy combined.
Step 1: Know Your Costs Inside Out
Before setting a price, calculate your true costs:
- Wholesale or manufacturing price
- Shipping and packaging
- Transaction & platform fees (Shopify, Stripe, PayPal)
- Marketing & ad spend
- Overhead (software, staff, storage)
👉 If you buy at $15, spend $5 on shipping, and $5 on ads, your real cost is $25. Selling at $29.99 looks profitable—until you realize you've only made $5 per sale before overhead.
Step 2: Research Competitor Pricing
Never set prices in isolation. Customers will compare your store to competitors instantly.
Manual method:
Check Amazon, Walmart, Target, and niche competitors to see their listed prices.
Automated method:
With PriceSense, you can:
- Track competitor prices automatically.
- Get alerts when they adjust prices.
- View historical trends to predict when discounts hit.
👉 Start monitoring competitor prices with PriceSense to avoid being blindsided.
Step 3: Choose a Pricing Strategy
Different products and niches demand different pricing approaches. Here are proven models for SMBs and dropshippers:
1. Cost-Plus Pricing
- Add a standard markup (e.g., 40%) on top of costs.
- Simple, but may not reflect competitor positioning.
2. Competitive Pricing
- Match or slightly undercut competitors.
- Effective for high-demand, commodity-style products.
3. Value-Based Pricing
- Price based on perceived value, not costs.
- Example: A $20 bracelet can sell for $60 if marketed as "premium handmade."
4. Penetration Pricing
- Launch lower to gain quick traction, then increase over time.
- Works well for new dropshippers or when entering competitive niches.
5. Premium Pricing
- Keep prices higher to signal exclusivity and quality.
- Effective in luxury or niche categories.
6. Psychological Pricing
- $49.99 feels cheaper than $50.
- Anchor pricing ("Was $99, Now $69") increases perceived savings.
Step 4: Test and Adjust
The first price you set won't always be the final one. Use data to refine.
- A/B test pricing: Run two versions of the same product at different price points.
- Track conversions: Low conversion rates with high traffic often mean pricing issues.
- Watch competitor moves: If competitors slash prices, you need to react.
With PriceSense, you can align your pricing tests with competitor monitoring to ensure you're never caught off guard.
Step 5: Factor in Customer Psychology
Humans don't think in spreadsheets—they respond emotionally to pricing.
- Charm pricing: $29.99 feels better than $30.
- Scarcity signals: "Only 3 left" or "Deal ends soon" create urgency.
- Bundles: "Phone case + charger for $39.99" feels more valuable than two separate purchases.
- Free shipping thresholds: $49 with free shipping often converts better than $39 + $10 shipping.
Common Pricing Mistakes to Avoid
- ❌ Copying Amazon's prices without checking your own costs.
- ❌ Launching with steep discounts that erode brand value.
- ❌ Forgetting to update pricing after supplier costs rise.
- ❌ Ignoring competitor discounts during peak seasons.
FAQ: Pricing New Products in E-Commerce
Q: Should I always undercut competitors?
A: No. Competing on value (faster shipping, bundles, loyalty rewards) is often better than racing to the bottom.
Q: How do I know if my price is too high?
A: If traffic is good but conversions are low, pricing may be the issue. Compare with competitors to confirm.
Q: How long should I test a price before adjusting?
A: At least 2–4 weeks, depending on traffic. Give your tests enough data to be reliable.
Q: Can price tracking help new product launches?
A: Yes. Monitoring competitors ensures you launch competitively from day one.
Conclusion
Setting the right price for a new product in your online store isn't about guesswork. It's about balancing costs, competition, strategy, and psychology.
By:
- Calculating real costs,
- Monitoring competitors with PriceSense,
- Choosing the right pricing model,
- Testing and adjusting with data, and
- Leveraging customer psychology,
…you'll set prices that maximize conversions and protect your margins.
🚀 Ready to launch your next product with confidence? Try PriceSense Free and build smarter pricing strategies today.
Start tracking competitor prices today
Join thousands of users optimizing their pricing strategy
